{
  "version": "study60-timing-listening-v1",
  "generated_at": "2026-09-13T06:52:29.251458+00:00",
  "source_data_sha256": "3c1ea61dc8d0531568f7c138c932dc6cbf38094fd73e4f8abd28418869c2e6d7",
  "ratings_source_sha256": "353d06a39f4f19bff4e18f9fa13b4f309144e7d87f3d279f7866e7712f19248d",
  "paired_personal_ratings": [
    {
      "pair_id": "P01",
      "gemini_sample": "S002",
      "gptlive_sample": "S001",
      "gemini_score": 4,
      "gptlive_score": 3,
      "preference": "gemini"
    },
    {
      "pair_id": "P02",
      "gemini_sample": "S003",
      "gptlive_sample": "S004",
      "gemini_score": 3,
      "gptlive_score": 3,
      "preference": "tie"
    },
    {
      "pair_id": "P18",
      "gemini_sample": "S036",
      "gptlive_sample": "S035",
      "gemini_score": 4,
      "gptlive_score": 2,
      "preference": "gemini"
    },
    {
      "pair_id": "P28",
      "gemini_sample": "S055",
      "gptlive_sample": "S056",
      "gemini_score": 4,
      "gptlive_score": 4,
      "preference": "tie"
    },
    {
      "pair_id": "P30",
      "gemini_sample": "S060",
      "gptlive_sample": "S059",
      "gemini_score": 5,
      "gptlive_score": 3,
      "preference": "gemini"
    }
  ],
  "samples": [
    {
      "sample_id": "S001",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "ro",
      "audio_sha256": "64c148c0134cbc119aaa42e34d0fc75b01fa73db3b9525eb7c59738304a3407b",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 3,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 4,
          "handling": 4,
          "personal_overall": 3
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "fail",
          "spoken_truth": "pass",
          "spoken_consent": "pass"
        },
        "notes": "it said thank you too many times ,also there was a pronunciation problem from caller",
        "recognized_provider": "gemini",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:16:10.923206+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "64c148c0134cbc119aaa42e34d0fc75b01fa73db3b9525eb7c59738304a3407b",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S002",
      "provider": "gemini",
      "language": "ro",
      "audio_sha256": "accb53b5f7c80394e50d8badbd2cb7d32e6f63a4f265330fb095b46d69915a3c",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 4,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 4,
          "handling": 2,
          "personal_overall": 4
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "fail",
          "spoken_truth": "pass",
          "spoken_consent": "fail"
        },
        "notes": "there was an audio gap, it blocked ",
        "recognized_provider": "gemini",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:20:44.565698+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "accb53b5f7c80394e50d8badbd2cb7d32e6f63a4f265330fb095b46d69915a3c",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S003",
      "provider": "gemini",
      "language": "en",
      "audio_sha256": "7ae30e560335d23777aee2b288fcde1ec59277edb870e279f536b200a268c554",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 4,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 4,
          "handling": 3,
          "personal_overall": 3
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gptlive",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:22:33.127101+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "7ae30e560335d23777aee2b288fcde1ec59277edb870e279f536b200a268c554",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S004",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "en",
      "audio_sha256": "5af5dbca378e0c3e79a4328cd310c49075e91aace9a76ccb97b655f020d866e4",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 3,
          "clarity": 3,
          "pace": 3,
          "audibility": 3,
          "handling": 3,
          "personal_overall": 3
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gemini",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:23:54.140604+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "5af5dbca378e0c3e79a4328cd310c49075e91aace9a76ccb97b655f020d866e4",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S005",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "en",
      "audio_sha256": "41a1e0b990f602305c56c70bb7d86f2fb9340ab220ead7e921f1992515c699dd",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 3,
          "clarity": 3,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 4,
          "handling": 4,
          "personal_overall": 4
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "pass",
          "spoken_truth": "pass",
          "spoken_consent": "pass"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gptlive",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:25:57.876929+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "41a1e0b990f602305c56c70bb7d86f2fb9340ab220ead7e921f1992515c699dd",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S034",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "en",
      "audio_sha256": "aa99d99ae51a1a420cf0275716c4955c53ac49b353ffbf24cb9ba07946da6266",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 4,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 4,
          "handling": 4,
          "personal_overall": 3
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gptlive",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:29:41.069477+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "aa99d99ae51a1a420cf0275716c4955c53ac49b353ffbf24cb9ba07946da6266",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S035",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "ro",
      "audio_sha256": "1b454314df9d424a96d9c48a79c0bb8785d8fd0d78656adcbe9433f28ef0589b",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 3,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 3,
          "audibility": 3,
          "handling": 2,
          "personal_overall": 2
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gptlive",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:39:29.690569+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "1b454314df9d424a96d9c48a79c0bb8785d8fd0d78656adcbe9433f28ef0589b",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S036",
      "provider": "gemini",
      "language": "ro",
      "audio_sha256": "fd9cf85a2b3c2fdfe17dcabbe6618f9e28dc5412161aebd26d4ccdb6c59c5cad",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 4,
          "clarity": 5,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 5,
          "handling": 4,
          "personal_overall": 4
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gemini",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:41:00.915737+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "fd9cf85a2b3c2fdfe17dcabbe6618f9e28dc5412161aebd26d4ccdb6c59c5cad",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S037",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "en",
      "audio_sha256": "7fdaf1d9440f1fd6da600eb798dbec3742aef2482b8fc1a1a684da3a5710ff5d",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 5,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 4,
          "handling": 5,
          "personal_overall": 4
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gemini",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:27:43.976145+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "7fdaf1d9440f1fd6da600eb798dbec3742aef2482b8fc1a1a684da3a5710ff5d",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S055",
      "provider": "gemini",
      "language": "ro",
      "audio_sha256": "cff5d9f995b882d72e4591445853e2f404abd8d9a33125c1cbdaab2cc92aa792",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 4,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 5,
          "audibility": 5,
          "handling": 5,
          "personal_overall": 4
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gemini",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:31:17.766578+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "cff5d9f995b882d72e4591445853e2f404abd8d9a33125c1cbdaab2cc92aa792",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S056",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "ro",
      "audio_sha256": "99126e108eb334f2c8af7d8b3d2c27357957a23e7990c20172474a2b2e69de1c",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 3,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 4,
          "audibility": 4,
          "handling": 3,
          "personal_overall": 4
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gptlive",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:33:04.968727+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "99126e108eb334f2c8af7d8b3d2c27357957a23e7990c20172474a2b2e69de1c",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S059",
      "provider": "gptlive",
      "language": "en",
      "audio_sha256": "d573db841750caecdc167ba461d2b215533081daa74efd819ba45a89c551b5e4",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 3,
          "clarity": 3,
          "pace": 3,
          "audibility": 3,
          "handling": 4,
          "personal_overall": 3
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gptlive",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:34:46.937394+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "d573db841750caecdc167ba461d2b215533081daa74efd819ba45a89c551b5e4",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    },
    {
      "sample_id": "S060",
      "provider": "gemini",
      "language": "en",
      "audio_sha256": "43e09ee9cb53a185857c50b8cd58930cfa6bff0bb58afe53d46c7fd25136c2d3",
      "personal_rating": {
        "ratings": {
          "naturalness": 4,
          "clarity": 4,
          "pace": 5,
          "audibility": 5,
          "handling": 5,
          "personal_overall": 5
        },
        "audio_review": {
          "caller_fidelity": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_truth": "unreviewed",
          "spoken_consent": "unreviewed"
        },
        "notes": "",
        "recognized_provider": "gemini",
        "saved_at": "2026-09-13T06:36:57.671957+00:00",
        "labels_previously_revealed": false,
        "audio_sha256": "43e09ee9cb53a185857c50b8cd58930cfa6bff0bb58afe53d46c7fd25136c2d3",
        "reviewer": "Patrick, GRAI Labs builder; subjective preference, not an independent panel"
      }
    }
  ]
}